Friday, April 20, 2007

"A moment of quiet reflection amongst the turmoil of politics"


Thought for the Day is a fixed part of my morning agenda. Over the years I have welcomed those two minutes during the Today programme when the political mud-slinging stops, and time is briefly given to consider the ethical, moral and spiritual aspect of an item of current affairs. Of the regular contributors, I have my favourites. Lionel Blue - of course, Tom Butler, Giles Fraser - who's anthology of writing in the Guardian, Church Times and Thought for the Day, "Christianity with Attitude" I am currently enjoying - and would heartily recommend to anyone - Christian or not - who cares about ethical issues. If you wonder or despair at how the term "Christian" seems to have become almost synonymous with a poisonous, narrow, right wing fundamentalism in a very short period of time, Fraser is a welcome antidote (you can download a pretty representative chapter for free here).
The one commentator who never ceases to annoy is Anne Atkins- scourge of gay people (especially Christian ones), wooly liberals and anyone else who doesn't subscribe to her definition of "family values" - almost to the point that I'm switching to Five Live as soon as I hear the words "from our Oxford studio, writer and broadcaster...". I know that at some point in the next 120 seconds I will be shouting and swearing at the radio as she puts forward some right-wing evangelical claptrap in her oh-so-reasonable but incredibly patronising manner. As another blogger put it "Why not play a recording of a pneumatic drill for two minutes? It would be more relaxing". Yesterday's Thought on abortion was disgraceful - as she started by stating that "No civilised person wants...to force a woman to give birth to a baby she dreads" but then goes on to equate abortion with the slave trade and the holocaust.
On today's programme I was glad to hear that the Today mailbox had been overwhelmed with critical responses to the item.
On a related topic, I was also glad to hear the discussion has reopened as to whether thought for the day should be opened up to representatives of non-faith groups - humanists, secularists etc. I see no reason why not. The faith groups do not have a monopoly on ethics. I'd welcome the thoughts of secular philosophers more than those of right wing tub thumpers like Atkins.

4 comments:

Tom said...

A brief list of people whose thought for the day might be interesing to me:

Mark E Smith
Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall
Sir Jimmy Saville
Chas and Dave
Huey 'Piano' Smith
Lord Biro
Martin Carthy
Mike Leigh
Shane Meadows
Anne Briggs
Ray Gosling
Ian Rankin
The Revd D Wayne Love
Robyn Hitchcock
Billy Bragg
Oliver Postgate
Charlotte Green

chickenhouse said...

From Stephen King's The Stand, p419:

" Huey "Piano" Smith, remember how that one went? Ah-ah-ah-ah, daaaaay-o... gooba-gooba-gooba-gooba... ah-ah-ah-ah. Et cetera. The wit, wisdom, and social commentary of Huey "Piano" Smith "

Sounds to me at least as coherent as some of the TTD contributors - open it up to the secular, that's my opinion.

Graham said...

Oooh - Fantasy Thought for the Day. Good game. And some very good picks from Tom. Assuming politicians are exempt...

Ian McKellen
Alan Hollinghurst
Julian Barnes
Shane McGowan
Clive Stafford Smith
Sharmi Chakrabati
Arsene Wenger
Raymond Briggs
Dick Gaughan
Bruce Springsteen
Spike Lee
David Chase
David Lodge
Jarvis Cocker
Alan Sugar

Tom said...

Raymond Briggs! Good call. A hero of my childhood. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fungus_the_Bogeyman

Jarvis would be interesting too.